April 17, 2023

The Ongoing Debate Over Maine’s Income Tax Elimination Proposal

Debate Over Maine Income Tax

The contentious proposal to eliminate income tax in Maine has sparked significant discussion among residents, businesses, and lawmakers. The bill, which aims to phase out income tax over a five-year period starting in 2024, is currently facing staunch opposition from Democrats who control both the House and Senate in Maine’s State House. Despite the uncertain future of the bill, its proponents argue that the bold move could lead to substantial financial benefits for Mainers, as well as businesses operating in the state.

Representative David Boyer of Poland has proposed the bill, which is designed to gradually reduce the state’s tax each year. This approach allows each state department to make necessary adjustments to their annual budgets, providing ample time to identify wasteful spending and implement required cuts. Boyer contends that despite a 20% increase in the state’s budget since the last budget, there has not been a corresponding improvement in services such as roads and other infrastructure projects.

However, opponents of the bill express concerns that the elimination of income tax would leave the state with insufficient funding to fulfill its responsibilities. This sentiment is echoed by House Speaker Mark Eves, a Democrat, who has stated that Maine’s tax system is broken and disproportionately benefits those at the very top. Eves believes that the current proposal would only exacerbate the issue.

The concept of eliminating income tax in Maine is not new. In 2015, then-Governor Paul LePage proposed an amendment to the state’s constitution to permanently prohibit the Legislature from imposing income tax on any person, starting in 2020. To compensate for lost revenues, LePage’s two-year budget plan aimed to increase sales taxes, cut off state revenue sharing with local municipalities, and impose taxes on certain non-profit organizations.

LePage’s proposal, however, met with fierce resistance from Democrats, who rejected the idea outright. In response, they offered a counter-proposal that called for a decrease, rather than elimination, of income tax, alongside lowered property taxes and an unchanged sales tax.

If the current bill is enacted and income from residents tax is abolished in Maine, the state would join the ranks of 10 other states that have either partially or completely eliminated their income tax. At present, seven states have no income tax, while New Hampshire and Tennessee tax only dividend and investment income.

Boyer concedes that the bill’s passage in its current form is unlikely. Nevertheless, he remains dedicated to advocating for tax breaks wherever possible, in the hope of alleviating the financial burden on Maine’s large retiree population, who live on fixed incomes, as well as benefiting higher-income “job creators.”

The bill is anticipated to reach the House floor within the next 4-6 weeks, where its fate will be determined. In the meantime, the ongoing debate over the elimination of income tax in Maine continues to generate strong opinions from both supporters and detractors. Whether the bill ultimately succeeds or fails, the conversation surrounding Maine’s tax system and potential reforms is not expected to dissipate anytime soon.

As Maine grapples with the prospect of income tax elimination, residents, businesses, and lawmakers must weigh the potential benefits against the concerns raised by its opponents. The outcome of this debate will have lasting implications for the state’s financial landscape and may influence similar discussions in other states across the country. Regardless of the bill’s eventual fate, the conversation it has sparked about Maine’s tax system and the need for potential reforms highlights the importance of engaging in informed, balanced discussions around such critical issues.


Contact Propono for help with the IRS and the Maine Tax Authority.

Share on Social Media
Back To Blog